Industry Report: Digital
The 9 Things Every Interactive Media Producer Should Think About Before Creating
by ANTHONY KAUFMAN
- The documentary filmmakers and media producers who are venturing out into the world of transmedia or interactive storytelling have advanced storytelling, but have spent much time, elbow grease, and sweat on their projects. As more producers seek to make more dynamic interactive projects, what should they keep in mind? Here are 9 things to keep in mind.
1. It's Not a Film
Interactive projects are not movies, even though they may include movie elements. As Tribeca's Ingrid Kopp says, "You have to recalibrate your expectations about what this work does: If you go to see a short film, it's going to be a difference experience than a feature film and the same is true for interactive work."
POV Digital's Adnaan Wasey agrees. "We go into these projects with a set of expectations that are partially formed by what our expectations about what a great film is," he says. "But people don't think as 'Bear 71' as a doc, they think of it as a cool website."
One of the big lessons Steve Bognar learned while making "Reinvention Stories," he says, was "finding that balance, of being true to our documentary practice"—"of patient observation, empathy, lyricism and poetry within the random moments of life"—"while pacing up the storytelling, breaking the stories into smaller nuggets, engaging viewers along the way, asking questions of viewers, giving them choices to make"—fulfilling "the speed and stimuli" that the web demands.
2. Have an Immediate Cool Tech Hook
"Pulling not from the tradition of film, but from advertising or entrepreneurship, you have to grab people in the first 10 seconds," says Wasey. "There is always a hook. With interactive, novelty is the big thing; today; it may even be trumping story. Right now, it's like the Lumiere Bros' 'Train Arriving at the Station.' People hadn't seen something like that before, and with all of the interactive docs that are getting noticed, it's not that the story is awesome, it's that they're getting pulled in by the technology."
3. Consider the Immersive Story
Sean Flynn, a documentary filmmaker who is attending MIT's Open Docs Lab starting this fall, says the best projects in the space have "an elasticity in terms of types of experiences: You can do the deep dive and get really immersed in it, but if you're causally checking it out, you can have a fulfilling experience in 5 minutes," he says.
Many transmedia watchers point to the NFB's "Welcome to Pinepoint" as particularly successful at merging the cinematic with the new platforms. "I think from a lot of people coming from traditional film, it's one of the projects that speaks to us," says Flynn. "Using a music score, sound design, and elegant transitions, elevated it above some flash-based multimedia project, and it had a nice narrative structure and a reveal. That's exciting to me."
4. Don't Overestimate Audience Interactivity
"Overestimating people's desire to be interactive can be a problem," says Ingrid Kopp. "You don't want to be constantly asking the audience to do work." Kopp cites two projects that achieve the right balance of interactivity and observation, Arte's "Alma - A Tale of Violence" and the NFB's "Bear 71."
Kopp calls the interactivity in both instances "soft," with not a lot of clicking. "You can just sit back and watch it," she says. In the case of "Alma," there is a more conventional interview-based 40-minute testimonial film, but viewers can also access a second-screen with supplemental visual material. Likewise, in "Bear 71," you can click around a map, "but it's still basically a 20 minute film," says Kopp. "It's not requiring you do to something interactive, but it's there, if you want it."
"Meets the audience where they are," she says.
5. But Give Them Something to Click
Julia Reichert ("Reinvention Stories") believes Internet "users"—as opposed to the viewer or audience of television or film—"tend to want to click on things, to play around with what they are watching. We did not really get this as we were making the piece," she says. "So I think we could have made the whole thing more interactive throughout. Use more game theory, get people engaged in that way. We could have broken more barriers, so to speak, between nonfiction storytelling and games/contests."
6. Personalize It
Kopp also heralds a new media project like "Take This Lollipop," which is less a documentary and more like a Facebook nightmare. But it makes the user directly part of the narrative. "I think it's so smart because it shows you how much information you give to Facebook. It's a simple Application Programming interface (API) and you're part of the story as you're doing it.
7. Keep it Simple
Steve Bognar says if he were to do it all over again, he'd make the "project smaller," he says. "The main feedback we're getting from viewers is that they haven't had time to go through the entire site, to watch all three acts of the stories. Even though, in total minutes, experiencing the site takes less time than watching a feature documentary, it's that different nature of the project. Most people start watching it, start going through the site, but then for one reason or other have to bail out - and not because it's boring! - and then tell us they intend to get back to it. This is frustrating to us, and a big lesson of scale: Smaller scale narrative works better on the web."
As Kopp says, "Less is more."
8. Cultivate a Community
Sundance's Cara Mertes (soon to head to the Ford Foundation's JustFilms) singles out a recent New Frontier Story Lab project called "Question Bridge," which also received backing from the Tribeca Film Institute and the Bay Area Video Coalition. "I love it, because it's got a community basis, and it calls out stories from everyday people in a powerful moving way. It creates community through time and space."
9. Partner Up
Brad Lichtenstein ("As Goes Janesville"), who developed the corporate accountability app BizVizz, which cost $75,000 to get up and running and was funded by ITVS' Project 360, says partnerships were crucial to making the app get noticed, though the same is probably true for any new media project. "If you don't make strong partnerships, you can build it, but no one will come," he says. "I've seen that mistake thousands of times." So upon the release of the app, Lichtenstein enlisted some big-influencers, such as the AFL-CIO and the Corporation for Public Broadcasting, along with those organizations that helped him create the app (the Sunlight Foundation, Citizens for Tax Justice, Good Jobs First) to get the word out via Thunderclap and other new social media mechanisms. "We trended in the Apple Store, and if you get up in new and noteworthy apps, it skyrockets," he says. BizVizz has now been downloaded 30,000 times.