Choose your language en | es | fr | it

Review: Lorna's Silence

email print share on facebook share on twitter share on google+

Turmoil in a globalised world


- This personal journey of a woman who ends up in the steel-making town of Seraing, trying to break free from her immigrant status and longing for a better life, touches the essence of humanity

Review: Lorna's Silence

Right from the start of the film, its title poses a problem. For what silence are we talking about, considering that Lorna speaks, replies, questions, asks and ends up soliloquising as if words were in fact the vital lifeline that sustains her? Or should we understand this silence as internal and the words expressed as an attempt to quieten a conscience which gives the young woman no peace until she stifles her turmoil? It is true that Albanian Lorna agrees to a marriage of convenience, but at the same time she tries relentlessly to avert the fate that hangs over the fake couple she forms with Claudy. The latter – a pathetic junkie – is himself a willing partner in a plot of which he becomes the victim.

(The article continues below - Commercial information)

In this brutal world – governed by the law of profit and the desire for personal enrichment, without concern for the consequences this could have on others, for it is precisely on the back and at the expense of others that this financial enrichment is achieved – Lorna’s scruples do not carry much weight. And yet, these scruples symbolise the gulf that separates her from Fabio, the scheming taxi driver who handles the young woman like a financial asset. He hopes, in this way, to become part of the real underworld of the Russian mafia, by arranging another marriage of convenience between Lorna and a mafioso gangster.

For his plan to succeed, Fabio needs to ensure that Claudy is definitively out of the picture. This is achieved not through the divorce procedures which Lorna tries to hasten but via more swift means that befit this human wreck who believes that, by giving up his drug addiction, he can win the love of this woman.

Perhaps it’s the power of this sentiment that the Dardenne brothers are celebrating here? The fact remains that Claudy does indeed come off the drugs and, without warning, the unthinkable happens: one evening when Claudy threatens to plunge into hell again, Lorna takes the initiative to give herself to him. But the idyll is short-lived for, after a dramatic narrative ellipsis, we realise that Claudy is dead.

At that point, the film changes tack completely. Lorna starts to ask questions again, for nothing can force her to keep quiet now, even if her life hangs only by a thread. For if she is pregnant, the deceased Claudy continues to live on inside the young woman. This is what she announces to her future husband. This is what Fabio finds out, even though the doctors refute her claim. However, Lorna still believes she is carrying Claudy’s child, because true love simply can’t fail to leave its trace…

Lorna’s Silence [+see also:
film focus
interview: Arta Dobroshi
interview: Arta Dobroshi
interview: Jean-Pierre et Luc Dardenne
interview: Olivier Bronckart
film profile
stands out as unusual in the Dardennes’ filmography. The camerawork is more restrained because the camera has become more of a witness than an actor. Moreover, the issue explored in Lorna’s Silence is much more vast than in the Dardenne brothers’ previous films, for through Lorna’s story the directors look at the world and globalisation. This narrative shift calls for another, cinematic shift already seen in the ending to The Child [+see also:
film review
film focus
interview: Luc & Jean-Pierre Dardenne
film profile
, with its homage to Robert Bresson’s Pickpocket. The Dardenne brothers’ films are thus still conceived as “a window onto the real” but will from now on focus as much on the formal rigour of the director of Money as on the pragmatism inherited from Rossellini.


international title: The Silence of Lorna
original title: Le Silence de Lorna
country: France, Belgium, Italy
sales agent: Celluloid Dreams
year: 2007
directed by: Jean-Pierre Dardenne, Luc Dardenne
screenplay: Jean-Pierre Dardenne, Luc Dardenne
cast: Arta Dobroshi, Jérémie Renier, Fabrizio Rongione

main awards/selection

Lux Prize 2008 of European Parliament 
Cannes 2008 Official Competition
Bset Script

Follow us on

facebook twitter rss


WTW Voz dormida EN
I'm Not From Here