Why Hast Thou Forsaken Me: The urge to draw a line
by Sabine Kues
- VENICE 2015: In her film, Israeli director Hadar Morag tells a complex tale about taking responsibility for one's own actions
Relying on a non-professional cast, in her first feature, Why Hast Thou Forsaken Me [+see also:
interview: Hadar Morag
film profile], Israeli director Hadar Morag introduces us to the responsibility that comes with being of flesh and blood through the young Palestinian Muhammad – an outsider in many ways. And so Muhammad cruises the streets of Tel Aviv on his BMX bike – when in the knife grinder Gurevich he seems to find something he was looking for. Just like Muhammad, Gurevich is a restless and, in a way, troubled man. His job takes him and his motorbike from slaughterhouses to gourmet restaurants, sharpening their knives. Muhammad, somehow taken with the figure of this free spirit, follows him. Finally taken on and introduced to knife sharpening, he finds out a secret about Gurevich, a similar kind of secret to the one he has also been hiding himself. While one of the two gives in to his body, the other literally draws a line – carved into the flesh. After her short film Silence, which was shown at Cannes in 2008 in the Cinéfondation section, her first feature – an Israeli-French co-production by Cassis Films and EZ Films – is being screened in competition in the Orizzonti section of the 72nd Venice Film Festival, and is also included in the Sala Web films selection.
Throughout Why Hast Thou Forsaken Me, Morag establishes several religious references, starting off with its title and the opening quotation: “And if thy right hand offends thee, cut it off and cast it from thee, for it is better that one of thy members should perish, than for thy whole body to be cast into hell.” With the subsequent images focusing on details of the body, the paragraph taken from the New Testament (frequently read as a reference to masturbation) remains in the viewer’s head, maintaining an atmosphere of unease. One of the first images shows close-ups of Muhammad's hands at work in a bakery. The scene is accompanied by the deafening clattering sounds of machinery. The imagery of hands at labour is crucial to the story, not only as we observe Muhammad masturbating, but also as we later on see repeatedly used close-ups of Gurevich's and Muhammad's hands sharpening the knives. An uneasiness remains throughout the film – intensified by a soundscape that is continuously broken up by the harsh rumbling of machinery, such as the recurring droning sounds emerging from the motor of the knife grinder.
To talk about Why Hast Thou Forsaken Me is to talk about its imagery – and especially the portrayal of corporality and physical labour. With almost no dialogue, the film gives an account of the special relationship growing between Muhammad and Gurevich. The latter seems to grow into a kind of role model for Muhammad, as can be observed from a scene that shows them both taking a cigarette break while Muhammad playfully copies Gurevich's every move. But the moment comes when Muhammad proves to be the one taking action and thereby taking responsibility for his deeds and his body. At times mystically enigmatic, Why Hast Thou Forsaken Me is no light fare, and shows the director's ties to her prior studies of Theology and Philosophy.
Did you enjoy reading this article? Please subscribe to our newsletter to receive more stories like this directly in your inbox.