email print share on Facebook share on Twitter share on LinkedIn share on reddit pin on Pinterest

TORONTO 2022 Platform

Review: Thunder


- Swiss director Carmen Jaquier’s debut feature film captures the restlessness of a young woman at the end of the nineteenth century and her need for affection

Review: Thunder
Benjamin Python, Lilith Grasmug, Noah Watzlawick and Mermoz Melchior in Thunder

Bathed in a deep sense of mysticism, reminiscent of masterpieces such as Song of Songs or the disturbing verses of Teresa of Avila, Thunder [+see also:
interview: Carmen Jaquier
film profile
- Swiss director Carmen Jaquier’s first feature film, presented in a world premiere at the Toronto International Film Festival and in the San Sebastián International Film Festival’s New Directors competition - has a timeless yet extremely modern air about it. Although the story initially revolves around the Catholic faith, its brutal restrictions and its negative views on sexuality and “women’s” bodies, this focus gradually gives way to a more universal reflection on love and sensuality as vectors for discovering oneself and others.

(The article continues below - Commercial information)

As explained by Jaquier herself, the film was inspired by a news item: two teenagers who set themselves on fire in a suburb of Berlin. It’s a tragic story which urged the filmmaker to ask herself where the limits lie when it comes to passions which can’t be freely expressed because they go against the norm. It was the discovery of her great-grandmother’s diaries - in which her relative addressed God in intimate tones, as if a confidante, recounting her torments and things she would never have confessed to anyone else - which transformed the initial screenplay into a historical event. The combination of these diaries and the determination of their author’s great-granddaughter is a film bursting with sincerity which depicts a rural world wrestling with fears and a desire for freedom which history has relegated to the margins, a film which embraces the marginalised perspective of a woman from the end of the nineteenth century who lives in the Valais mountains. Aside for these indispensable narrative elements, Thunder draws its strength from many powerful visual references (made clear at the beginning of the film, which opens with emblematic, painterly photos), including that of Giovanni Segantini, who had an unrivalled talent for painting the rural world.

The film tells the story of seventeen-year-old Elisabeth (played by the incredible Lilith Grasmug) who, in the summer of 1900, while preparing to take her vows, is forced to return home to her family in a Valais region valley, to help them with their farming work. The reason for this sudden change of course is the death of her sister Innocente, the cause of which remains a mystery. Back in the valley where she was born, Elisabeth is no longer a child and must contend with the emotions coursing through her and the discovery of her sister’s diary, which only exacerbates them. What’s recounted here is a veritable fight for survival and for the right to explore one’s own inner world free from the concepts of good and evil which loom over the valley like an oppressive cloud.

The trigger for this silent revolution is an encounter between the protagonist and three young people from her village: Emile (Benjamin Python), Pierrot (Noah Watzlawick) and Joseph (Mermoz Melchior), who knew her sister very well and shared her visceral, almost Franciscan need for communion with nature. By virtue of magnificent photography (by Marine Atlan) which is, at times, reminiscent of Jane Campion’s The Piano, the film seems to throb with the emotions felt by the young protagonists who, far from representing conventional, heterosexual sexuality revolving around procreation, discover the joy of being loved, caressed and cuddled, a joy which their parents have totally deprived them of. In this instance, sexuality is born out of an urgent need to re-connect with their humanity, for a nigh-on mystical communion with God and nature, which comes from a very natural need to reconnect with one’s own body. Discreet yet determined, Elisabeth turns into a spokesperson for a desire which has the potential to raze everything to the ground, if given free reign.

Thunder is a powerful, visually on-point and majestic first film, revealing a director who’s determined to impose her own point of view.

Thunder is produced by Geneva’s Close Up Films in co-production with RTS Radio Télévision Suisse. WTFilms are handling international sales.

(The article continues below - Commercial information)

(Translated from Italian)

Did you enjoy reading this article? Please subscribe to our newsletter to receive more stories like this directly in your inbox.

Privacy Policy